Ready to Renovate?Book a Phone Consultation
Spur Jewelry - Heirloom Jewelry Renovation | NYC

Every so often, we receive requests to create a wearable talisman using seemingly unconventional materials, such as baby teeth.

Though this concept seems strange to some, jewelry made to commemorate this pivotal moment in a child’s life dates back hundreds of years. The practice of turning a child's first teeth (also referred to as “milk teeth”) into jewelry was popularized in Victorian-era England, when Queen Victoria turned her eldest daughter Princess Victoria’s tooth into a brooch. At a time when infant mortality was at a high, milk teeth jewelry was a way to celebrate a major milestone in a child’s life.

Baby Tooth Jewelry FAQs

How do I start a baby tooth project?

Select one of our favorite baby tooth designs above on this page or book in for a consultation to start a custom baby tooth project. We typically begin with a photo of your baby tooth. We'll want to hear all about your project!
To help you envision your specific baby tooth in one of our designs, we will send you a custom sketch of options personalized for you and the proportions and scale of your exact tooth in a selection of our designs.

Can I use my own gold and gemstones in my baby tooth project?

Yes! We're happy to talk through using your own gold in your baby tooth project or incorporating your heirloom gemstones. We can also source a variety of gemstones for you including birthstones. Cabochons, especially turquoise, rubies, sapphires, and emeralds all look especially beautiful with baby teeth.

How do I mail in my baby tooth?

After you place your order, we will send you an insured shipping label and packaging instructions to send your tooth to our studio.

How long does it take to make the charm?

Our baby tooth charms take approximately 8 weeks to create in our NYC studio.

More Teeth


We consider the gold tooth to be a symbol of prosperity and survival. In dreams gold teeth are often interpreted as symbols of new opportunities and gifts. Basically, we love teeth so much we made a teeny and shoppable tooth stud.